Hendon No-Show

The demonstrators outside the Hendon Hall Hotel on Sunday morning didn’t know that the person they had come to demonstrate against was over 2000 miles away in Israel.

Tzipi Livni was Foreign Minister of Israel when they launched their attack on Gaza a year ago, but is no longer in office. This means she has lost her immunity against prosecution under international law, and lawyers supporting the Palestinian cause had apparently obtained a warrant for her arrest on international war crimes charges in a London court.  Acting on advice from the Israeli authorities that it would be possible for her to be arrested should she visit Britain (or Spain, Belgium or Norway)  she had decided not to travel here and delivered a speech to a largely elderly Jewish audience at the Jewish National Fund conference by video link some time on Sunday afternooon.

Photographically the demonstration with a little less than a hundred people inside a pen outside the hotel complex was not particularly of interest. There were some few banners and flags and a certain amount of animation whenever a car pulled up to enter the gateway next to the pen after being checked by the security guards, but really not a lot was happening.

So it was a little of a challenge to produce interesting pictures – but of course I wasn’t going to set anything up – it goes against my principles. I did what I think you always have to do, watched the people taking part carefully and picked out scenes that struck me as visually more interesting, framing carefully. There were only one or two other actual photographers present which made it a little easier, not having to bother much about getting in the way of other people.

© 2009 Peter Marshall.

This man attracted me because I saw him as a man holding not a placard but a gun, its barrel the the stem of the key with its text “thE RIGHT Of return”, his right forefinger on the trigger and the orange scarf a part of the stock. I took a series of pictures, but couldn’t quite get the expression I wanted.

The there were images like this, where the placard stands out and tells a story:

© 2009 Peter Marshall

and of course I wrote about the story for Demotix and also on My London Diary.  Normally I might have framed more tightly, perhaps as a vertical eliminating the man on the phone at the left, although I liked having the ‘Free Palestine’ placard above his head. But there were other reasons to frame it like this (or rather to use the frame like this), partly that I wanted to use a closer image of this demonstrator with the other side of his placard (which there is also a story about that in the piece on My London Diary/Demotix.)

Altogether I spent over an hour taking pictures, and used around a dozen of them with the story on Demotix.  As usual you can see a looser edit  – around 20 pictures from the roughly 200 exposures I made – on My London Diary, along with a similar but slightly updated version of the story.

Little Brown Mushroom

Little Brown Mushroom Books were the publishers of Alec Soth‘s “The Last Days of W”, a self-published 48 page newsprint publication that came out at the time of the 2008 Paris Photo. Although I very much liked the pictures on the wall there, I couldn’t bring myself to pay even the lowish price asked for this because it just didn’t seem to me to do justice to his work – and it was better to leave it to my memory and what I felt were rather better reproductions on the web.  The 10,000 copies soon sold out, and many have written in praise of the publication. Probably one day it will become a high priced collector’s item, although doubtless by then fading and falling to pieces.

Alec Soth used to have one of the more interesting blogs written by a working photographer – in my blogroll still, and most of us wondered how he ever found the time to do it. By October 1, 2007 he had obviously got to wondering too, and made his last post, though his archived blog is still on line and still makes some good reading.

But the good news – which I read in a new post there – is that he is now a contributor to a new Little Brown Mushroom blog, like the book company based at his studio address in St Paul, Minnesota, USA, where he is one of a team of six on the blog.  (Check out Carrie Elizabeth Thompson‘s rather minimal web site too.) Little Brown Mushroom Books has also just published  Lost Boy Mountain its first zine by another of the team, Lester B. Morrison – his first publication. You can of course find out more about it there, although again I don’t think I’ll be buying.

As the first post on the blog on Dec 12 said, “This is a place to talk about good books (our own and others)” and Soth has given his own response to The Future of the Photobook – currently under discussion elsewhere – in the blog.  But following  the death last week of Larry Sultan,  Soth has contributed a generous and thoughtful post, Larry Sultan, Pictures From Home.

Copenhagen Crisis

I decided not to go to Copenhagen and join the many protesters and press there. I don’t like travelling and have things I want to do in London, and enough of my photographer friends were going for me to feel my input on the spot wasn’t that vital.

I should really have gone, after all I’ve been an environmental campaigner – if not always a very active one – for more than 40 years, since the late 1960s, when frankly few people realised there was an environment and we had to take some responsibility for it. I think it was 1966 or 7 that I got rid of the only car I’ve ever owned,  and a couple of years later, much as I dislike speaking in public, was talking about cutting energy use,  shifting from private to public transport, cutting down on meat and moving towards a sustainable future.

In the last ten or fifteen years, as someone who I think has considerably more to offer behind a camera than in front of a microphone I’ve tried to tackle some issues related to cities and in particular to photograph and publicise environmental protest.

So really I should have gone to Copenhagen, but I couldn’t work up a great deal of enthusiasm about it, not least because I think it is almost certainly going to fail. For one very simple reason, which this Climate Rush banner brings up:

© 2009 Peter Marshall
‘Equity’ on the Climate Rush procession to Heathrow

It isn’t easy to read the text on the small version on the blog, so here it is:

EQUITY: Emission quotas must be per capita; the rich have no more right to pollute than the poor.

[You can read what is on the other two Climate Rush banners, Truth and Justice here, as well as many more pictures from that Heathrow protest.]

It’s a tough message for those us in the rich world, but one that needs to be at the base of any just settlement.  But impossible to see it passing the US Senate – or for that matter some other governments.

You’ll know the UK government is taking the environment seriously if they announce an end to airport expansion, cancelling the third runway at Heathrow, banning domestic flights,  ending the road programme, lowering all speed limits, abandoning plans for coal-fired power stations and a huge investment in green jobs to make drastic cuts in energy use and a massive shift to renewables.  Until then, whatever government is in power is just indulging in greenwash.

© 2003 Peter Marshall

But although Copenhagen was from the start doomed to fail to reach the radical agreement that is needed, there is still a possibility it could lead to some minor steps in the right direction. So I’ve just become number 11,103,301 to sign the ‘Save Copenhagen: Real Deal Now!’ petition being organised by global web organisation  Avaaz.org  and invite you to consider doing the same if you haven’t already.

They are hoping to make it the “largest petition in history in the next 72 hours!” Here’s some more from their site:

“An Avaaz team is meeting daily with negotiators inside the summit who will organize a spectacular petition delivery to world leaders as they arrive, building a giant wall of boxes of names and reading out the names of every person who signs. With the largest petition in history, leaders will have no doubt that the whole world is watching.

Millions watched the Avaaz vigil inside the summit on TV yesterday, where Archbishop Desmond Tutu told hundreds of delegates and assembled children:

“We marched in Berlin, and the wall fell.
“We marched for South Africa, and apartheid fell.
“We marched at Copenhagen — and we WILL get a Real Deal.”

Copenhagen is seeking the biggest mandate in history to stop the greatest threat humanity has ever faced. History will be made in the next few days. How will our children remember this moment? Let’s tell them we did all we could.”

No, I haven’t done all I could have done, but despite my reservations I think it is worth trying to put a little pressure on in this simple way which might just get a little more progress. Even if it only makes a very small step for mankind it is after all better than throwing money away into space.

Bells Not Bombs

I made life a little harder for myself on Thursday by forgetting to check my camera settings before taking pictures. No excuse, I just forgot.

Normally I have a roughly 35 minute train journey to London and often either a bus or an underground ride to the location when I’m photographing demonstrations, although quite are few that take place in Central London are in easy walking distance from the mainline station I arrive at.

When I get on the train I usually sit down and take out my camera and check everything is ok. If I’m not taking the train I do this at home before setting out.  All the basic stuff like spare batteries for camera and flash, spare CF cards, cleaning cloth, lens cleaning kit live in my bag along with my camera and my normal set of lenses, so when as usual I find I’m in a rush and have to pick up my bag and run for the train I can be fairly sure I’ll have what I need.

On the train I usually check the lens surfaces and clean if necessary,  get the camera to clean the sensor, format the CF card in the camera and restore the camera settings to my defaults. The Nikon lets you store sets of custom settings – and I almost always use the same set.

Then I’ll think about where I’m going and what I’ll be taking (so far as I know),  the weather and anything else and decide what would be suitable initial settings for the job. I decide on the appropriate ISO and whether or not to use auto-ISO and if so, on the highest setting, and make  appropriate settings for the aperture and shutter speed for aperture priority,m shutter priority and manual modes so that should I switch to them from P (either accidentally or on purpose) I don’t have too much fiddling to do or get exposure horribly wrong.  I make sure I haven’t left the metering on spot – which I use at times, but if you use it when you think you are in centr-weighted mode can be embarrasing.  And a few other little things like that, so that when I arrive somewhere if things are already happening I can just pick up the camera and start taking pictures.

Because I know if things are happening, that’s what I will do, and if the camera isn’t set up sensibly it may well be some time before I notice. I’m not very good at noticing the information in the viewfinder, rather single-minded about looking at the picture and solving the visual problems. I do occasionally glance at the image on the back of the camera, but ‘chimping’ disturbs the flow, and in any case quite a few problems don’t show up obviously there.

I’ve also got the problem that I can’t actually see the display on the camera back at all clearly (or the top plate display) when I’m working. I need glasses to read, but have never used to wearing them when using a camera. My Nikons have just enough eyesight correction available so I can see the viewfinder image clearly (though its rather blurred for most other people if I ask them to take a picture with it.) One day I’ll have to have an expensive talk with my optician and start working with glasses on, but I don’t look forward to it.

On Thursday I was distracted and forgot my usual routine, missing one very important point when I took out the camera. I’d left the ISO at 3200 from when I’d been taking pictures in a very dimly lit pub a couple of days earlier.

Of course I should have noticed the ISO and rather unusual settings for me such as 1/500 fll displayed very clearly below the image in the viewfinder,  but I actually managed to shoot several hundred images without doing so!

Fortunately, the D700 does a pretty marvellous job at ISO3200 (if it didn’t I would have noticed earlier as I do occasionally zoom right into images on the screen and put my glasses on to check, particularly that eyes are sharp in portraits.)  So back in Lightroom, with just a touch more noise reduction and sharpening than normal I had more or less perfect results.

3200 is just a little extreme, and viewed at actual size on screen I could see just a little more noise and a little less detail than normal, but an actual size image would be 31 inches (79cm) wide if my screen was that wide.

© 2009 Peter Marshall

But looking on the positive side, I think this image wouldn’t have worked so well at the ISO 400 I would probably have been working at had I got my act together.

And perhaps the extra depth of field does help in a picture like this:

© 2009 Peter Marshall

so perhaps I ought to work at ISO 3200 more often. Although it might make sense to edit the EXIF data before trying to smuggle it past Alamy quality control.

The event was a demonstration by Trident Ploughshares at the UK HQ of the leading company involved in making nuclear bombs in Britain, at the AWE at Aldermaston. Of course Lockheed Martin is a US company, and there are allegations that it is also producing warheads for US use at their Aldermaston bomb factory, probably in breach of international war.

Given the Cold War ended 20 years ago and we are supposed to support an international treaty aimed at stopping the proliferation of nuclear weapons, we might ask why we are paying a US company billions of pounds to make more. Any government that is serious about making savings and repaying our huge national debt should be ditching our nuclear programme rather than expanding it.More pictures and more about it on My London Diary.

Kurds on Hunger Strike

© 2009 Peter Marshall

Really there was just one obvious picture to take, so I took it.  The hunger strike is over the treatment of their imprisoned national leader Abdullah Ocalan, now confined in a small, poorly ventilated ‘death-pit’, and here he is in the middle of three men on hunger strike, just slightly larger than life.

Of course I did take a few more – though not many – but I don’t think they add a lot to the story, which you can read on My London Diary.

COP Out Camp Out

After all the demonstrations during the day on December 5, the climate campers took their tripods and tents to Trafalgar Square and set up camp in the middle of it, around the traditional Christmas tree and below Nelson.  And although they had no permission to do so and the Mayor of London isn’t pleased nobody much interfered with them.

Although originally they had only intended to camp for 48 hrs, they decided to stay while the talks in Copenhagen are taking place.  I called in on my way to another event on Tuesday and took a few pictures, although not very much was happening.

© 2009 Peter Marshall.

Which perhaps made it hard work to take pictures.

© 2009 Peter Marshall.

Though free mugs of tea were on offer to anyone who wanted one, and I took advantage of the offer.

More on My London Diary.

The March And The Wave

Saturday’s main event was organised by the Stop Climate Chaos Coalition, made up of over a hundred organisations whose only common feature is their concern over climate change and which have a combined membership of around 11 million – about 1 in 6 of the UK population.

I first came across them a few months back when they organised a demonstration outside the Department of Energy and Climate Change and minister Ed Miliband came out in person to speak to them.

© 2009 Peter Marshall.
A real Minister (with a worried aide) and a false cardinal
with other demonstrators outside the DECC in September.

Although they didn’t succeed in getting all 11 million to come to ‘The Wave’ there were roughly 50,000 marching though London (so many that some were still at Trafalgar Square or in Whitehall at 3pm and missed the actual wave when Parliament was surrounded) making this the largest demonstration on climate change in the UK to date.

© 2009 Peter Marshall

If the main event lacked the political bite of the Campaign Against Climate Change (who were taking part as one member of the coalition) there was certainly plenty of enthusiasm, fancy dress and blue face paint to make for some visually striking images.  The ‘Wave’ itself was perhaps something of an anti-climax, and the crush of photographers close to Big Ben at the head of the demonstration made photography difficult.

© 2009 Peter Marshall

Especially those photographers who hold their large DSLRs out at arms length in front of other photographers.  Photographic etiquette generally stops other still photographers from actually walking in front of you as you are taking pictures (nothing stops some guys taking video), but somehow a growing number seem to think its OK if you just hold your camera in front of others.

More pictures from the march and the final wave on My London Diary.

“Up Yer Bum COP 15!”

Another rare bit of humour in Saturday’s Climate march, with a banner from the “Polartariat”:

© 2009 Peter Marshall.

Along with a rather nice polar bear.

The anti-capitalist block joined the march at Berkeley Square and for a hundred yards or two this banner was at the head of the march, until stewards and police managed to persuade them to roll it up and go back and join in further back.

Although the block apparently had three banners, I only saw one other, with around twenty or thirty people, including both anarchists and a few Stalinists carrying flags with the message ‘For Bolshevism. The group left the climate demonstration before ‘The Wave’ around the Houses of Parliament.

More comment and pictures on My London Diary.

Police Dig Deeper Hole?

Police seem determined to spurn the usual sage advice about stopping digging in their relationship with photographers.  Read today’s news piece by Chris Cheesman on the Amateur Photographer, Police crackdown on City photographers, which recounts how Graham White was stopped by a security guared while photogarphing a building in Silk St. A police spokeswoman is reported as having said that the police advise photographers to inform a security official of their intentions, prior to taking pictures.

Yesterday AP reported yet another case of photographer harassment, in which a man taking pictures in Hounslow High Street was arrested, handcuffed and taken to Hounslow Police Station where he was held for three hours for a for a ‘Section 5’ Public Order Offence before being issued with an £80 fine and released. He intends to take the case to court rather than pay the fine.

Also today, in The Register, John Ozimek titles his piecePolice snapper silliness reaches new heights: City of London employ new ironic policing tactics‘ and recounts how London Tonight reporter Marcus Powell with an ITN crew filming a story about an earlier incident in which seven police officers in three cars and a riot van were called to deal with architectural photographer Grant Smith who was photographing one of the city’s Wren churches were questioned by police.

These incidents appear to be getting more common, despite various campaigns and demonstrations by photographers, a Home Office Circular, statements by the Home Secretary and ACPO, a debate in the House of Commons, comments in the Lords, features and leading articles in newspapers… But it seems that there is nothing and nobody that can bring the police under control.

You can of course read some more about the situation on the ‘I’m a photographer not a Terrorist‘ web site, which also gives details of a Mass Photo Gathering in defence of street photography to take place in Trafalgar Square at 12 noon on Saturday 23rd January 2010.  Something to put in your new Diary. See you there!

In the meantime, I suggest we all take our cameras with us whenever we go into town (any town)  and take pictures, even if we are only going shopping or to the pub and intend to delete the pictures (unless the police tell us to.)  That way we might wear the bastards down.

If you’ve got a camera, use it. Otherwise soon you won’t be able to.

Trust Me, I’m a Banker

You may well not have heard of WACT, the ‘World Association of Carbon Traders‘ and some of the slogans on the placards they carried in Saturday’s Climate march may have surprised a few, though it would have been hard to miss the irony in ‘Trust Me, I’m a Banker‘ or others such as ‘Greed is Green‘. They also stood out from the others taking part in not following the recommended dress code of blue and preferring pin-stripe suits and ties.

© 2009 Peter Marshall.
‘Carbon Trader = Eco Crusader’ and WACT’s logo is CO2$

I don’t believe that photographers should pose people or tell them what to do when taking photographs – though I might occasionally ask someone to turn their placard so I can read the message, in general I’m at pains not to intervene in the situation I’m photographing. But as I photographed this group of ‘city gents’ (and ladies) coming down the road I couldn’t resist pointing out they were approaching the Institute of Directors, with the hope that they might in some way react. And they did, running across the road to pose for a group photograph in its doorway.

© 2009 Peter Marshall

Of course it is only too obvious at the moment that many people are profiting from climate change and that carbon trading is one way that the rich can make money and keep in charge – markets are always controlled by those with money.

More about the WACT and more pictures on My London Diary.